
Part 1
Okay. Deep breath. Hold steady. Stay calm.
I am writing this post about a subject that terrifies me. Inherited furniture. Family heirlooms. Everyday objects handed down from one generation to the next. Artwork, chairs, china, pianos, paintings, crystal, knick-knacks, photos. It is about my journey with the family silver, and all the joy, pain, grief, guilt, sense of loss, sense of connection…the myriad of emotions associated with it.
This is not a controversial subject. At least, I don’t think it is. Because every single person you and I know has a story to tell, and an opinion about this subject. They range from the “you must hold onto every single item ever given to you” camp, to people who tell you they are not the least bit sentimental, and don’t keep anything passed down from generations before.

A Thanksgiving table including the silver candelabras and silver-plated bowl. Also a tiny view of my mother’s silver flatware.
If you’re at all like me, you fall somewhere in the middle. So, I am going to tell you about my journey with the family silver. And I would love to hear your story…all your stories. We all have them.
This particular story I am sharing really focuses on my mother’s side of the family. Her mother was an orphan; my grandmother and her sister (my great-aunt) were raised by an adoptive family in upstate New York. She often talked about growing up on a farm, leaving her window open in the winter to let the snow in, sleigh rides at Christmas time in the country. And she often worried that her two granddaughters would never marry because we weren’t domestic enough. (Happily, she was wrong on both counts.)

The silver candelabra in a different season. I can only hope that my family sees the humor!
Her husband (my grandfather) came from money. Lots of money. Oklahoma oil field money. (Our family still gets oil royalty checks.) His family, my great-grandparents owned a home in Tulsa filled with the treasures of the well-to-do. Sterling silver, original paintings, crystal, china, a Chickering pianoforte. Based on the stories I was told, my great-grandmother held on to her matriarch position very tightly.

My great-grandmother left this Chickering pianoforte to my mother. I played when I was younger, and am currently trying to learn how to play the piano again.
My grandparents married, had 3 children together (for context, my mother was born in 1925), but the marriage ended early. I’ve checked with my brother and cousins; we all, each of us, seem to have a different story as to why. Nevertheless, as a consequence, my grandmother raised 3 children nearly single-handedly through the depression and WW II. Keep in mind, this was before the days of alimony checks and child support.

An original Bernard Pothast painting my great-grandmother specifically left to my mother. I love the contrast between the simplicity of the painting and the ‘rococo’ style frame.
I’m going to skip over the years striving to keep her children fed and housed; years that also included tragedy and heartbreak. If there was one word to describe my grandmother, it would be indomitable. All 4-feet-11-inches of her. I truly loved her, and wish to this day I knew more about her and her life.
When her children were grown, my grandmother went to work in a patent law office. With this income, she bought a lovely, cozy home in a Los Angeles suburb, and proceeded to fill it with antiques. She had an excellent eye, and bought mahogany furniture, Limoges china, crystal, sterling silver, and furniture in beautiful fabrics and amazing colors.

A Venetian Amethyst Glass Decanter with silver overlay.
Moving forward several decades, my mother became the recipient of much of this household treasure trove from both her mother and her paternal grandmother (the matriarch). After my grandmother passed, we worked on moving some furniture pieces along. And after my mother passed, I moved a few more furniture pieces along.
But my day of reckoning came when we moved from Southern California to NE Indiana and I brought with me the mahogany chest my father had brought back from the far east during WW II. For as long as I can remember, this carved, mahogany chest has held all of the family crystal and silver. As I was unpacking to settle into the Dupont house, I started emptying it out.

Instant overwhelm. Complete loss of perspective. My back literally felt like I was carrying a load of bricks. There was just SO MUCH! Worse, I had nowhere to store it. The Dupont house has no built-ins or corner hutches. Despondent, I packed it all back in. This was the start of my journey with the family silver.

Even when we lived in San Diego, and Red Shutter Cottage was the go-to for Thanksgiving dinner and Easter lunch, I never even scratched the surface of using this amazing collection. And now that we are in a new city, my role as hostess of holidays has essentially evaporated. Was there any opportunity in the future for me to use any of these pieces? I couldn’t imagine that ever happening, which didn’t help with my overall outlook.

Fast forward a few months, and I am sitting at lunch with a group of friends. Full of righteous self-pity, I complained about the bounty of beautiful pieces I was saddled with. One of these amazing women perked up and said “My daughter-in-law loves to collect and use older china, serving dishes, and silverware.” I nearly fell out of my chair! Really? Where does she live so I can pack it up and drop it all off at her front door? The answer…she lives in Georgia. I did reach out to the daughter-in-law in Georgia, and she responded by confirming she would be interested. But it never really went anywhere. Georgia is about a 10 hour drive, one-way.

However…a few months later it came about that the above mentioned daughter-in-law from Georgia was going to be in the Summit City for a week of various family celebrations. Again, I reached out to her and asked her to come over during her visit to look at the china and silver and see if she was interested. She indicated she would do so, and I had an incredible sense of elation that my journey with the family silver just might come to an end.

The sterling silver candelabras just added the perfect Gothic touch to my Halloween mantel.
I set about displaying the entire collection in the living room and dining table. I even borrowed 2 folding tables from a friend so I could showcase all the pieces.
But then I panicked a little. My brother and his 2 daughters (my nieces) actually deserved the first pick of all of this. It didn’t seem fair that a perfect stranger could possibly pick up and take something that either one of my nieces or my brother might want. I called my older niece and insisted she come over ASAP to pick out anything she MIGHT want. We scheduled a Face Time session with her sister, my younger niece, so she could also pick out what she wanted. They ‘sister-squabbled’ over a few of the pieces, and then made trades about these plates or that serving platter.

In the end, my heart was completely overfilled. They each selected a substantial haul. I was so incredibly happy when I looked at everything they chose to keep. My older niece has 2 children, and I know my younger niece plans on having a family. I realize I have no say in this whatsoever, but I truly and deeply hope that some of these family heirlooms may one day have a place in the lives of their children.
Then, my brother REALLY stepped up. He took the beautiful cranberry crystal glasses that my grandmother had collected, as well as the green Portuguese glass goblets my mother so adored. I have always loved them, and happily so does he. We are going to search Facebook Marketplace to find a display cabinet to put in his living room so they can be seen and appreciated.

Here are the Portuguese green glass goblets that were my mother’s favorites. Also included are my Grandmother’s limoges plates and bowls, and my mother’s sterling silver wedding flatware.
Part 2
The daughter-in-law from Georgia never did make it over, and in all honesty, I was perfectly fine about it. Because it was then that I realized that the REAL goal was to pass these pieces on to my family. I was so happy that my nieces and brother had selected to keep so many pieces from their great-great-grandmother, great-grandmother, and grandmother. Even though there was still quite a bit left after all that, I knew exactly what to do next.
Actually, the next thing I had to do was REALLY think about what I wanted to keep. So, what did I keep? Enough to feel that I have honored the long line of women before me who loved beautiful pieces, and grateful to be able to keep the pieces that spoke to me and I appreciated.
A stunning silver pitcher. A pair of sterling silver candlestick holders.

A beautiful, huge, and very ornate silver-plated bowl.

My mother’s sterling silver flatware. There is actually so much flatware that both my older niece and I EACH have a dozen complete settings.
I also kept my Grandmother’s Limoges china, and my Mother’s bamboo pattern wedding china, as well as her sterling silver serving pieces.
With these decisions settled, I reached out to an auction house here in Fort Wayne. After several phone conversations and a flurry of photos sent to them, we were ready to move forward. Sailor and I packed a box to deliver to the auction house, filled with the pieces that were left, including this huge silver-plated mirrored tray.

It’s ornate. It’s heavy. It’s just huge (did I say that already?).
What in the world would I ever do with it?

We met with my auction house contact who was very gentle and kind with me. We finalized all the paperwork, and we turned to walk out to the truck. I wasn’t even out of the building when the tears started in. Trying to hold back sobs, I got to the truck, and Sailor started up the engine. We didn’t even make it out of the parking lot when I managed to choke out the words “Stop the truck”. Without a word, he turned the truck around.
I climbed out, ran over to the warehouse doors and pounded on them until a very curious face peeped out at my tear-streaked face. I asked for my contact person and she was right there. We opened the box and I took out the mirrored tray. “I’m not selling this one.” I announced, oblivious to how obvious it was. Probably not a bit surprised by my emotional drama, she responded by simply saying “Of course not.” Feeling calmed and settled, the tray and I climbed back into the truck and home we went.

And despite my fears of never entertaining again, I do use these treasures. I’m currently serving as President of the women’s group I belong to. We hold the monthly board meetings here at the Dupont house, and afterwards I serve lunch. (Feeding people helps ensure 100% attendance!) When I am serving lunch, I always use my mother’s wedding flatware and either my Grandmother’s Limoges plates or my mother’s bamboo pattern china.

One day I will use the mirrored tray, the ornate bowl, and the silver pitcher, perhaps for a fall display or a Christmas celebration. They are all so stunning, reminiscent of the table settings from Downton Abby and ‘The Age of Innocence’.

There is still another story of how much of my grandmother’s furniture I kept (as well as let go of). When I can come up with enough courage, I will write about that journey.

My grandmother’s mahogany Tambour desk. I can still see her sitting there, writing bills or sending letters.
What has your journey been? How do you keep or let go of inherited items left to you? Are they gifts, or are they burdens? Do the memories bring you joy? Please do share with me and others reading this post.
From our home to yours!
Kristine



Good morning, Kristine! I am so happy that you kept that mirrored silver tray! It is absolutely stunning! As I was reading, I was so scared that you were going to sell it, and I was so relieved to read that you kept it. I am sentimental to a fault. My cabinets and home are full of family heirlooms and there is no way that I could ever part with them. I have my grandmother’s furniture from her formal living room upstairs in a family room. I’m trying to get the courage to recover her chintz sofa, but I’m struggling. It’s crazy, I know. In my heart, I know that if she was here she would be helping me shop for the fabric. She loved to decorate and had a beautiful home. Thank you for writing this post . I can relate so much! I hope you have a wonderful week ahead!
Shannon – I know how much you value your beautiful heirlooms. You do such an incredible job of displaying them, and using them to make your home feel so inviting and warm. I love how you brought together your Grandmother’s furniture together to create your beautiful family room. I still have (and will keep) several furniture pieces from my Grandmother. You clearly understand the dilemma I faced with the family silver, and I appreciate your insight! I’m not sure why I could part with the silver tray; it’s an incredible piece and a direct link to my Great-Grandmother. You will see it again, likely a fall or Christmas post. Thank you so much for stopping by!
I totally understand, My sisters and I have sorted, offered, donated and sold so much and yet I still have so many treasures from my mother and grandmothers tucked away in this tiny cottage, because I just can’t bear to part with them. I’ve recently made more of an effort to display and use some of the pieces, but like you, unless I’m serving 30 people multiple meals, with floral arrangements and enough candles to start a fire, it’d be impossible to use all at once…but my heart won’t let me let it go.
Kim – your comment gave me a little laugh. You do get it – the tug and pull and the “I-just-can’t-let-this-go!” dilemma. Having those pieces and treasures help keep us linked to our past and our family. Seeing them and using them brings comfort and connection. My emotional response to letting the silver tray go caught me by surprise, but I am glad I went back for it, despite my slightly embarrassing emotional melt down.
I fall into the not-sentimental category and all that silverware etc would do my head in because I have nowhere to put it and no use for such beautiful pieces. That being said, I totally understand wanting to hold onto pieces that remind us of our loved ones. My mum had SO much stuff that she’d collected and curated, but when the time came to move and significantly downsize, it became the albatross around her neck – the antique dealers already have too much stock (people are buying less these days) and collectors aren’t paying what they used to. She sorted, sold, donated, packed, unpacked, re-sorted, gave some to my brothers and myself (nowhere near as much as she’d hoped we’d take off her hands) and then sold and donated some more. It’s been a huge journey for her where the stuff she owned eventually owned her. I will never do that to myself or my kids – so I’ll admire other people’s beautiful keepsakes, cutlery, furniture, ornaments etc but will do my utmost to keep my stuff within manageable levels – I think you’re finding that balance too (but I can see it would have been an emotional time for you). Enjoy those memories you’ve kept and the knowledge that the rest went to happy homes. 🙂
Leanne – There are so many sides to this conversation. And you have to follow your heart to do what is right for you and your family. Keeping belongings and heirlooms at a manageable level for your peace of mind is critical. That was what I struggled with; keeping what I knew I could, and deciding to let go of what I never really saw as valuable or useful. Thank you for weighing in with a different perspective. I hope your mom arrives at a level of equilibrium with regard to her collectibles. Thank you for stopping by!
Hope you have recovered from your back surgery. Anxiously awaiting our return to the Turnstone family! Enjoyed your story. I have been overwhelmed by my brother in law’s collection of books and furniture. My husband is my nature a pack rat which he inherited from his mother. My house is small and some how has become the recipient of many items of little or no value except they were his. There are now over 100 books which will never be read.
Deb – Thank you for your get-well wishes! I am healing well, and can’t wait to get back into the pool. I do miss you all so much – trust me! I know you have been overwhelmed with belongings from your brother-in-law. It may be a slow process, but you may be able to work through all that. Thank you so much for stopping by; I will see you soon!
I loved reading all about your family and the heirlooms you have inherited. It’s hard to decide what to do with things, especially when there is a lot so you’ve done amazingly.
I felt quite emotionally invested so by the time I got to the bit in your story when you ran back into the auction house I wanted to reach into the screen and give you a hug!
We live differently to how our ancestors did so the things we need are different but it’s still nice to have a few bits from the past and even better if we use them regularly. I was lucky to inherit a beautiful tea set from my late grandma and I love using it, it’s a real connection to the past 🙂
Julie – thank you for the ‘virtual’ hug! I wasn’t expecting to get so emotional about it, but I too am glad I ran back for the mirrored tray! You are right – the challenge is that we have such different lifestyles now than in the past, but I do love using pieces from my grandparents. Even more rewarding was the response from my nieces and how they wanted to keep pieces from our family’s past. Thank you for stopping by.